The People News, a free newspaper serving Cleveland Tennessee (TN) and Bradley County Tennessee (Tn).





Of Bradley County Tn.


OCTOBER  2007

                            The People News, a free newspaper serving Cleveland and Bradley County Tn.

HOME

BACK ISSUE ARCHIVE

EDITORIALS

LETTERS

CONTACT US

IDENTITY THEFT:
Law enforcement style!

By Joe Kirkpatrick

Two things I want to make clear from the beginning: The account of the following events took place in Hamilton County, and the name of the victim has been changed to protect her from further harm.

Last winter, Whitney Dombrosky, an honor student at UTC, was on her way home to Cleveland when she was stopped for speeding near Hamilton Place Mall. The stop was uneventful: The officer took her license, wrote her a ticket for speeding, returned her license, and perhaps even told her "have a nice day." Little did Whitney realize this routine stop would turn her life into a nightmare at a later date.

A couple of weeks later, she called the number on the ticket to see what the fine amount was and to see if she could pay it my mail. The lady on the phone said, "I have the amount, but don't you want to know when your court date is?" Whitney replied, "you mean I have to come to court over a speeding ticket?" The lady replied, "not for a speeding ticket but you do on your other charges." Whitney, getting agitated, said "WHAT OTHER CHARGES??" The lady then said, "possession of a controlled substance and driving without a license that you were charged with last night." Whitney, now worked into a frenzy, very loudly said, "I'VE NEVER BEEN ARRESTED FOR ANYTHING!!" After a long silence, the lady on the other end, mutters

Joe Kirkpatrick

"Oh my God! - Hold on for a minute." After about a 5 minute wait, a man gets on the phone and informs Whitney she evidently has been the victim of identity theft, and she needs to contact all of her credit card companies, because evidently, some other girl is using her identity. After talking for a few minutes, the man agreed to email Whitney a mug shot of the woman who was arrested who used her name. Whitney took the picture, then emailed it to everyone in her address book, and put a title on the email: DOES ANYONE KNOW THIS GIRL WHO STOLE MY IDENTITY?

Amazingly, within a hour, she received a call from her friend Lauren, who excitedly told her, "Whitney, you're not going to believe this - my dad and I had lunch at Red Lobster in Chattanooga yesterday and that girl was our server! I remembered her name tag  and I called my dad and he still had his credit card receipt, and he said on it was "sever: Dombrosky."

Whitney called the manager at Red Lobster, explained what had happened, and the manager said she would give the server Whitney's phone number and see if she would call her. Luckily, the sever did call, and believe it or not, her name really was Whitney Dombrosky! Our Whitney called the police department in Hamilton County, and they informed her she and the other Whitney needed to come to the station to get it "straightened out." The other Whitney agreed to do so. Even after they met at the police station, our Whitney was told she would still have to go to court with the other Whitney. A few weeks later, they appeared together in Hamilton County Sessions Court, and explained to the judge what had happened. A detective at the hearing had the gall to accuse "our" Whitney of being in collusion with the "other" Whitney, and demanded to know if they were not in it together, how they knew each other. Judge Bob Moon didn't buy the detectives argument, and admonished him for even saying it. He ordered all charges against our Whitney to be dismissed, including her speeding ticket, plus ordered her record be expunged. I did a background check on her for this article through the TBI, and her record does now come back clean.

How did this happen? For the record, the "other" Whitney did not steal "our" Whitney's identity. This is what happened: Our Whitney got a speeding ticket, and all of her information was put into the system. Remember what the other Whitney was arrested for? Possession of a controlled substance and NO DRIVER'S LICENSE. When a clerk was typing in the information, they did not have a driver's license number for the "other" Whitney. When they typed in the name "Whitney Dombrosky", all of "our" Whitney's information from her ticket popped up, so they just filled in all of her information on the arrest of the "other" Whitney, making both girls information "our" Whitney's. In a way, our Whitney was lucky that she made that inquiry about her speeding ticket when she did, otherwise, a felony warrant may have been sent to Bradley County for her arrest. Identity Theft is a bad problem, but even worse when a law enforcement agency is to blame!

In this age of information sharing, we have already been informed of how important it is to routinely check our credit report for misinformation. This incident also is an example of why if you are issued any type of summons or ticket from a law enforcement agency, it is a good idea to later have a background check run on yourself to make sure something like this doesn't happen to you.
.

HOME

BACK ISSUE ARCHIVE

EDITORIALS

LETTERS

CONTACT US